Mine wastes create harsh recruitment conditions for forest tree seedlings, especially waste rock piles where erodible slopes are prone to drought. Plantations using fast-growing tree species can potentially accelerate the conversion of degraded mine sites into forests through facilitation of tree recruitment, while contributing to the stability of slopes. In this study, hybrid poplars were tested as a means of achieving reclamation objectives by providing shelter for forest tree seedlings on waste rock slopes (3H:1V ratio) in the Canadian southern boreal region. Density effects of young hybrid poplars were assessed on the emergence and survival of early, mid and late successional species, naturally occurring or hand-seeded, and on the understory micro-environmental parameters in plantations of different spacings (1?×?1, 2?×?2, 4?×?4 m and control without planted trees). Results were also compared in 2?×?2-m plantations with and without a hydroseeded herbaceous cover, traditionally used to control erosion in slopes. During the 2nd growing season of the plantations, seedling emergence of naturally established Salicaceae (Populus and Salix) species followed a quadratic pattern along the density gradient, as emergence values were higher under an intermediary density. Nonetheless, decrease in light transmission emerged as a limiting factor of seedling survival for these early-successional, shade-intolerant species by the next summer. Following a spring sowing experiment in the 3rd growing season of the plantations, emergence rates for later-successional Picea glauca and Abies balsamea seedlings increased with hybrid poplar density. During their peak emergence period, in early season, higher soil moisture content was found under denser cover. However, at the end of the third year of the plantations, only A. balsamea showed moderate increase in early recruitment success rates under denser tree cover. In hydroseeded plots, a competitive effect of the herbaceous cover was observed on Salicaceae emergence and A. balsamea survival. These results suggest that planting of young plantations without a hydroseeded cover may offer a more suitable solution in order to quickly provide early recruitment opportunities for later-successional seedlings in waste rock slopes. Despite this, a significant decrease in moisture content recorded during the second half of the 3rd growing season under the 1?×?1-m cover, compared to the 2?×?2-m, likely signalled an increasing competitive effect from hybrid poplars, which may compromise their nursing potential in the longer term. Therefore, further monitoring is imperative for a better understanding of longer-term facilitation and competition interactions between nurse trees and understory seedlings in waste rock slopes, where competition for limited resources, such as water, may be severe.

1.A broad and diversified group of compounds, secondary metabolites, are known to govern species interactions in ecosystems. Recent studies have shown that secondary metabolites can also play a major role in ecosystem processes, such as plant succession or in the process of litter decomposition, by governing the interplay between plant matter and soil organisms. 2.We reviewed the ecological role of the three main classes of secondary metabolites and the methodological challenges and novel avenues for their study. We highlight emerging general patterns of the impacts of secondary metabolites on decomposer communities and litter decomposition and argue for the consideration of secondary compounds as key drivers of soil functioning and ecosystem functioning. 3.Synthesis. Gaining a greater understanding of plant-soil organisms relationships and underlying mechanisms, including the role of secondary metabolites, could improve our ability to understand ecosystem processes. We outline some promising directions for future research that would stimulate studies aiming to understand the interactions of secondary metabolites across a range of spatio-temporal scales. Detailed mechanistic knowledge could help us to develop models for the process of litter decomposition and nutrient cycling in ecosystems and help us to predict future impacts of global changes on ecosystem functioning.

Background and Aims

Abandoned lands are increasingly used to establish fast-growing tree plantations, and are often rapidly colonized by a high density of herbaceous undergrowth. These weeds are generally removed since they compete with trees for resources, in particular soil nutrients. However, mixing herbaceous litter with the litter of planted trees could also stimulate the activity of decomposers and associated nutrient release due to an increase of litter quality (lower C:N ratio), plant diversity (more diverse litter traits) and water holding capacity. The objective was to determine the impact of herbaceous litter on the litter decomposition process of white spruce and hybrid poplar litters alone or in mixtures.

Methods

Litter mass loss rate, nutrient release and decomposer communities were monitored on single and mixed-species litters using litterbags during two years in three plantations types (hybrid poplar, white spruce and mixed plantations). Litters within mixtures were separated by species to identify species-specific responses of leaf mass loss.

Results

N release of all litter types increased with the presence of herbaceous litter. This finding could be linked to the greater abundance of decomposers and fungal biomass brought about by the herbaceous litter. Addition of herbaceous litter had no effect on spruce litter mass loss but had positive effects on poplar and mixed spruce/poplar litter mass loss. Abundance of fungi and mites was more affected by litter quality, whereas the abundance of collembola was more affected by the diversity of resources than by litter quality.

Conclusions

In these 10-year plantations with poplar, increased litter mass loss for poplar and mixed litters and N release associated to the presence of herbaceous litter showed that weeds may change soil C sequestration and N cycling.

La plantation d’arbres est une bonne façon de réintégrer les sites miniers restaurés au sein des paysages forestiers naturels. L’objectif principal de cette étude était d’évaluer l’effet de l’épaisseur et de la nature du sol sur l’établissement d’arbres et leur accumulation de métaux lorsque ces arbres étaient plantés sur des rejets miniers non acides en conditions boréales. Deux expériences de terrain ont été réalisées pour évaluer la survie, la croissance et les concentrations de métaux traces et de nutriments de plusieurs espèces d’arbres, dont 2 à croissance rapide (Pinus banksiana, Larix laricina, Populus maximowiczii × P. balsamifera, P. × canadensis × P. maximowiczii et Salix viminalis), plantés dans des sols (couche de surface ou sous-sol, 50 ou 20 cm d’épaisseur) sur des roches stériles et des résidus épaissis, respectivement. Tel qu’attendu, dans l’expérience avec des roches stériles, la croissance des arbres plantés sur le sol de surface a augmenté (×2) par rapport à ceux sur le sous-sol en dépit d’une fertilisation minérale. La croissance des arbres plantés sur des sols de surface minces était réduite, parallèlement à une diminution des concentrations foliaires de N, cependant l’épaisseur de soln’avait aucun effet sur la survie des arbres. Le saule des vanniers semblait bien adapté et polyvalent pour la végétalisation de rejets miniers à court terme puisque sa survie est restée maximale indépendamment de la nature (sol de surface ou sous-sol) ou de l'épaisseur (50 versus 20 cm) de sol et du type de rejets (stériles versus résidus). La croissance et la survie dumélèze laricin étaient bonnes sur les deux types de rejets (sauf pour le sous-sol seul). À l’opposé, les peupliers hybrides n’ont pas obtenu de bonnes performances au niveau de la survie (roches stériles) ou de la croissance (dans des sols minces sur résidus) dans les conditions étudiées. Aucune des espèces d’arbres n’a accumulé de métaux traces dans son feuillage à partir du sol dans ces conditions de croissance sur des résidus miniers non acides possédant de faibles concentrations de métaux traces, mais la survie du saule des vanniers devrait être suivie à plus long terme pour évaluer les effets délétères de l’accumulation Zn.

Tree species influence the litter decomposition process by influencing litter quality and soil microclimate. Furthermore, over the long term, trees could promote soil communities that are particularly capable of degrading the litter they encounter most often. Thus, plant litter could decompose faster when placed in the habitat from which it was derived than in a foreign habitat, which has been termed home field advantage (HFA) of litter decomposition. In mixed-plant species environments however, it is not known whether a specific decomposer community under one tree species is affected by the presence of another tree species in the vicinity. To address this question, we tested if spruce and poplar litters showed HFA in mono-specific and in mixed species plantations under each tree species by reciprocally transplanting litter in the two plantation types. Decomposition rates, as well as the composition and ability of decomposer communities to degrade the different types of litter, were monitored during two years. Only spruce litter exhibited a faster decomposition rate at home. This HFA could be explained by higher abundance of decomposers. Furthermore, cellulose and poplar litter decomposed less or similarly in spruce plantations, suggesting that soil communities of that environment were capable of specifically degrading spruce litter. In mixed plantations, HFA was in the same direction as in mono-specific plantations, but was not as strong, indicating that HFA is sensitive to the surrounding plant community. Furthermore, this “mixed environment” had synergistic effects on decomposition rates under poplar trees. These ‘tree environment-specific’ results highlighted the possible importance of spatial distribution of each litter on decomposition rates in mixed stands. Thus, the influence of litter dispersal should be taken into account in future studies.

The use of trees under intensive management is particularly important for rapid fiber production in boreal regions. Mixed-species plantations using species that have complementary ecological niches, such as hybrid poplar and white spruce, potentially can maximize the use of resources and, consequently, increase productivity. In the context of climate change, vegetation and soil carbon sequestration is of a particular interest as part of a possible means of compensating for CO2 emissions. Since higher productivity leads to higher CO2 sequestration, the use of mixed-species plantations could improve the ecological service of carbon storage compared to mono-specific plantations. We compared above-ground and soil C storage of nine-year-old mono-specific plantations of white spruce and hybrid poplar with mixed plantations of these two species. Soil carbon was evaluated by separately sampling four soil horizons, while aboveground carbon was assessed from tree biomass estimates using allometric relationships. Mixing white spruce and hybrid poplar exerted a substantial synergistic effect on above-ground and soil carbon storage. This positive effect was due to greater productivity of poplar (47% of biomass increase) and great accumulation of litter in soil surface horizons (52% L-horizon carbon increase) of mixed-species compared to mono-specific plantations. These results imply that in addition to wood production gains by poplar trees, mixed-species plantations of hybrid poplar and white spruce promotes greater carbon sequestration than mono-specific plantations of either hybrid poplar or white spruce, an important aspect of forest ecosystem services.

Tree planting presents clear advantages for mine reclamation that is aimed at achieving rapid reclamation of forested landscapes. A greenhouse study was conducted to evaluate the capacity of non-acid-generating, thickened tailings to support six boreal tree species during two growing seasons. One treatment was thickened tailings alone fertilized with inorganic N, P, and K fertilizer or chicken (Gallus gallus domesticus) manure. A thin layer of overburden topsoil was used to cover the tailings and was compared with topsoil alone, where normal tree growth was expected. Two amendments were also tested: overburden topsoil and vermicompost from food wastes. The presence of alkaline thickened tailings under the thin layer of acidic topsoil had a positive effect on tree height and root biomass (broadleaved and jack pine [Pinus banksiana Lamb.]) by increasing topsoil pH and available Ca concentrations, which decreased Al, Zn, and Mn phytoavailability to trees; however, root contact with the tailings also increased their Cu concentrations. In thickened tailings that were mixed with topsoil, C/N ratios increased along the experiment from 21 to 40, a value where N immobilization by microorganisms occurred, as suggested by low N concentrations in tree tissues. In consequence, tree height growth (broadleaved) and biomass (conifers) were reduced. Amendment with compost raised the electrical conductivity (3.4 dS cm"1) to thresholds limiting broadleaved survival, while conifers showed a generalized decrease in biomass production. No trace metal contamination of the trees occurred in the mixtures, probably due to the near-neutral pH conferred by the tailings.

Il y a un intérêt pour les plantations d'espèces à croissance rapide de peupliers hybrides et de saules au Canada. Cet intérêt s'explique à la fois par le taux de croissance rapide et le potentiel élevé de rendement de ce type de système de production. Cependant, leur établissement et leur entretien requièrent des investissements considérables. Les efforts de recherche sur les comparaisons de productivité de différents clones ou espèces, les croisements, la physiologie, la nutrition, la sylviculture, la gestion des ravageurs, les méthodes de récolte, les aspects socio-économiques et la transformation industrielle contribuent à maximiser la production de fibre et à minimiser les coûts de production. L'objectif de cet article est de décrire brièvement des travaux de recherche en cours ou récemment complétés sur les plantations d'espèces à croissance rapide de peupliers hybrides et de saules et de discuter de leur utilité et de leurs impacts à des fins d'applications pratiques.